We hear lots of accusations, but mostly a pointing out of the problems on one side or the other. We hear there were “many sides” to the conflict. We hear there were fine people on both sides. We hear that rights were violated, but just whose rights has come into question.
I personally addressed only one side of the conflict. Then publicly and privately received questions and comments like:
“Why don’t you condemn the counter protestors who were using violence?”
“The Nazis were assembled peacefully, Antifa is in the wrong.”
“We should be against any hate and violence, not just the one side.”
“Black people hate white people too, why do you only address white people?”
I don’t think the “what abouts” and the “many sides” arguments hold much water. I don’t think they are morally equivalent. And I don’t think it is remotely helpful to suggest they could be.
Not all sin is equal.
The Bible certainly does not define all sins as equal. Jesus talks about varying degrees of judgment, even mentioning one sin that is unforgivable. He compares one person’s sin to a speck of dust and another’s to a plank of wood. He says it is too easy to pay attention to the little (and easier) stuff while ignoring “the weightier matters of the law: justice, mercy, and faith.” Paul lists particular sins that will exclude a person from God’s Kingdom. Proverbs lists seven sins God specifically hates.
The idea that all sin is equal is not scriptural. This doesn’t mean that all sin is not serious or without consequence, just that all sin is not the same. Not in its impact, not in its origins, not in its destruction.
Our experiences teach us this as well. Would you rather be lied to or murdered? Would you rather someone gossip about you or burn down your home? It is no contest.
How we respond to the events of Charlottesville (as well as past and future situations) needs to be taken in this light.
As a follower of Jesus, I practice non-violence. I agree that hate cannot drive out hate and I believe with all my heart that loving our enemies is the way of true transformation. I stood in the pulpit on Sunday and said that all people, even white supremacists, are made in the image of God.
As such, I hold that punching an unsuspecting person in the face is wrong. Even if that person is a literal Nazi.
But I believe it is more wrong to be a Nazi.
Both are wrong. One is worse.
There were various things that were wrong in Charlottesville. But the first wrong, and the worst wrong, was people showing up in the name of white supremacy.
Rallies of people carrying Klan flags and chanting Nazi slogans and hoping to intimidate other people should not be met with, “but whatabout” excuses, exceptions, or distractions.
There is no “yeah but.”
White supremacy is wrong. Full stop.
It was the worst kind of wrong this weekend. Not only did it lead to injury and death, it was the cause of all the trouble in the first place.
White supremacy carries with it the weight and repercussions of our history.
White supremacy has systemically oppressed people of color in our country since day one.
It enslaved, it segregated, it lynched, it dismissed, it intimidated, it wounded, it terrorized. White supremacy elected officials and passed laws and waged war and built an empire.
And I realize I just used past tense here as if this is only a thing of the past. It still goes on doing most of these same things today. It is not locked away in history books. It is alive and well and marching down the street in broad daylight.
It is unjust. It is ungodly. It is evil.
So when you show up under that banner, your sin is the greater one. You don’t get to “yeah but.”
To do so attempts to level a playing field that is not remotely level. It seeks to eradicate painful abuses that have been suffered at the hands of one side of the conflict for centuries.
It does not matter to me who threw the first punch. It doesn’t matter to me that you had permit. It doesn’t matter that you supposedly didn’t plan to use the bricks and bats and guns and vehicles you brought.
You hate people because of the color of their skin or because of their religion. You applaud and fight for the oppression of human beings. You use fear. You seek to eliminate. You incite. You have and continue to make life miserable for people who are different than you.
Whatever other wrongs may have transpired, you are the problem here.
Even if there had been no violence or death or counter protest, you and your behavior should be loudly opposed by those who have any moral fiber. Just because it is legal doesn’t make it right.
Any response to your vile hatred is not comparable to the vile hatred that you have chosen.
All sins are not equal. And this weekend we saw deep and tragic sin.
This is incompatible with the things that make our country great. And it is completely incompatible with the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
To my white sisters and brothers, let us reject this kind of thinking and behavior. Let us examine our hearts and root out any hate and prejudice that lies within. Let us educate ourselves on the struggles of those who are different than us. Let us learn in humility and be moved to action.
Let’s stop the “whatabout” nonsense and get down to business addressing our problem with race as a nation, as a people, as a church.
Not all sins are equal and this is one of our worst.
To my sisters and brothers on the receiving end of this and other forms of racism, my heart breaks for you. You do not deserve this. I am praying for you. You belong here and you are not alone.
“Justice is a joy to the godly, but it terrifies evildoers.” Proverbs 21:17